
Mondrian South Beach
Best for social, design-forward stays with spacious suites and bay views — good if you want a lively poolside and easy access to South Beach's restaurants and shops.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Mondrian South Beach is an all-suite, design-forward bayside hotel on Biscayne Bay with a social pool scene and Mediterranean dining for travelers who want contemporary style and easy access to South Beach. Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is a small, historic ultra-luxury beachfront resort in Surfside for travelers who prioritize beachfront privacy, full-service luxury and a quieter atmosphere.
Updated · about 10 km apart

Best for social, design-forward stays with spacious suites and bay views — good if you want a lively poolside and easy access to South Beach's restaurants and shops.

Best for ultra-luxury beachfront stays, privacy, and a refined, historic Surf Club setting with Four Seasons service and signature dining.
When Mondrian South Beach wins: Pick Mondrian if you want larger suite layouts with kitchenettes, a lively waterfront pool and easy walking access to Lincoln Road, the Art Deco District and South Beach nightlife.
When Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club wins: Choose the Surf Club for a smaller, quieter ultra-luxury hotel on the ocean with direct beach access, a full-service spa, and high-touch Four Seasons service.
Bottom line: Mondrian is the better fit for travelers seeking contemporary design, space and a social bayside scene near South Beach. The Surf Club is the choice for travelers who want beachfront luxury, a historical property feel, and a more private, resort-style stay.
| Category | Mondrian South Beach | Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, social, design-focused | Historic, formal ultra-luxury, beachfront |
| Location | Biscayne Bay, West Avenue — walkable to South Beach neighborhoods | Oceanfront in Surfside, quieter northern Miami Beach corridor |
| Size | 220 rooms (all-suite) | 77 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; adult-oriented atmosphere (21+ to check in; spa 18+) | All ages (not adults-only); 21+ minimum check-in age applies at property |
| Pools & water access | One bow-shaped outdoor pool overlooking Biscayne Bay; cabanas and private daybeds by reservation | Two outdoor pools plus direct ocean/beach access and a beach bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Baia Beach Club (Mediterranean waterfront) plus Gem Bar lobby lounge | Three restaurants including Le Sirenuse Champagne Bar and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Baia Beach Club — adult-only spa with Himalayan salt sauna, steam rooms, couples' suite | Full-service spa with treatment rooms, Turkish bath/Hammam, sauna and accessible facilities |
| Known for | Marcel Wanders–designed interiors, all-suite layouts and a lively pool/restaurant scene | Historic Surf Club legacy combined with Four Seasons service and beachfront setting |
| Accessibility & family features | Welcomes children; pools kept adult-oriented; complimentary beach cruiser rentals | Welcomes children; accessible features include wheelchair-accessible spa, fitness center and pool hoist |
| Meeting & event space | Extensive event space (multiple studios, Sunset Ballroom, Tower/Penthouse options) | Two meeting rooms and event facilities for smaller gatherings |
Mondrian South Beach sits on West Avenue facing Biscayne Bay, a short walk or quick drive to South Beach hotspots.
Choose Mondrian for proximity to South Beach attractions and a bayfront perspective rather than direct oceanfront.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is a beachfront hotel in Surfside with direct ocean access and a quieter neighborhood feel.
Choose the Surf Club for direct beach access and a quieter Surfside location while staying within easy reach of north Miami Beach shopping and Miami International Airport.
Mondrian is all-suite (about 220 rooms) with kitchenettes and layouts aimed at space and comfort.
Mondrian suits travelers who want larger suite-style rooms and in-room conveniences like kitchenettes.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club has a small roster of rooms and suites focused on luxury finishes and ocean views.
The Surf Club is for travelers who prefer a compact, highly serviced room inventory with oceanfront suite options.
Dining at Mondrian centers on Baia Beach Club, a Mediterranean waterfront restaurant, plus a lobby lounge.
Mondrian works well if you want a single, consistent waterfront dining destination with a social, relaxed vibe.
The Surf Club offers multiple dining venues including Mediterranean-influenced Le Sirenuse Champagne Bar and full room service.
The Surf Club is aimed at guests who expect several curated dining options, including signature restaurant experiences and robust room service.
Mondrian's signature outdoor feature is a bow-shaped pool overlooking Biscayne Bay with cabanas and daybeds.
Mondrian focuses on a fashionable bayfront pool experience rather than direct ocean swimming.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club provides two outdoor pools plus direct ocean/beach access and a beach bar.
The Surf Club is the pick for travelers who want to combine resort pools with direct beach access and full-service beach amenities.
Mondrian offers a 4,000-sq-ft adult-only spa, 24-hour fitness center and a social poolside scene.
Mondrian blends a daytime social pool/nightlife vibe with an adult-only spa and round-the-clock fitness options.
The Surf Club offers a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness with a quieter, luxury resort rhythm.
The Surf Club prioritizes spa and service-led relaxation over an on-site nightlife scene.

Mondrian — all-suite layouts with kitchenettes and larger suite options make it better for longer stays and families.

Four Seasons at The Surf Club — direct ocean access, beach bar and a small luxury room inventory for a quiet beachfront stay.

Mondrian — Baia Beach Club and the bow-shaped pool create a social daytime atmosphere with regular happy hours and poolside service.

Four Seasons at The Surf Club — smaller property size and Four Seasons service favor privacy and individualized attention.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is oceanfront with direct beach access; Mondrian faces Biscayne Bay and is not directly on the Atlantic beach.
Both welcome children. Mondrian is described as adult-oriented but still family-friendly with large suites; the Surf Club is a quieter, full-service resort that also accommodates families.
Four Seasons lists three restaurants and several bars in the supplier facts; Mondrian centers most dining around Baia Beach Club plus the Gem Bar.
Mondrian is within walking or short rideshare distance to South Beach attractions. Four Seasons at The Surf Club is farther north in Surfside and requires a drive to reach central South Beach nightlife.
Explore how Mondrian South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·