
Mondrian South Beach
Best for travelers who prefer quieter bayside views, larger suite layouts, and a design-led all-suite stay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Mondrian South Beach is an all-suite, design-driven Bayside hotel on West Avenue for travelers who want quieter Biscayne Bay views and suite-style rooms. The Shelborne By Proper is a fashionable Collins Avenue resort-hotel on the ocean side for guests who want direct beach access and a central South Beach location.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for travelers who prefer quieter bayside views, larger suite layouts, and a design-led all-suite stay.

Best for guests who want to stay steps from the Atlantic, Collins Avenue shopping, and South Beach nightlife.
When Mondrian South Beach wins: choose Mondrian for larger suites with kitchenettes, a calmer bayside setting, and Baia Beach Club’s waterfront Mediterranean dining without being in the middle of Collins Avenue traffic and crowds.
When The Shelborne By Proper wins: pick The Shelborne for direct access to a private stretch of sand, an Art Deco Collins Avenue position within walking distance of Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive, and a fashion-forward hotel identity tied to Proper’s lifestyle brand.
Bottom line: both hotels deliver style and easy South Beach access; Mondrian skews toward suite comfort and a quieter bayfront experience, while The Shelborne puts you closer to the Atlantic, Collins Avenue shopping, and beach time.
| Category | Mondrian South Beach | The Shelborne By Proper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-forward, relaxed, bayside resort with Marcel Wanders interiors | Fashionable, Art Deco-era resort-hotel on Collins Avenue |
| Location | 1100 West Ave — faces Biscayne Bay (west side of South Beach) | 1801 Collins Avenue — beachfront on Collins Avenue (east side) |
| Size (rooms) | 220 rooms (all-suite property) | 251 rooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; hotel is adult-oriented in atmosphere (min. check-in age 21) | All ages welcome; not adults-only (min. check-in age 21 listed) |
| Pools & waterfront | Bow-shaped outdoor pool overlooking Biscayne Bay with cabanas and loungers | Outdoor pool plus private beach access and beach cabanas/umbrellas |
| Restaurants & bars | Baia Beach Club (Mediterranean waterfront restaurant) + Gem Bar lobby lounge | Pauline (on-site dining) + coffee shop and multiple bars (3 lounges listed) |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Baia Beach Club — roughly 4,000 sq ft; adult-only treatments and steam/sauna offerings | On-site spa (wheelchair-accessible); size/name not published |
| Known for | All-suite rooms, design interiors, bay views and Baia Beach Club waterfront dining | Long-running South Beach name paired with Proper’s lifestyle recognition and beachfront position |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues including Sunset Ballroom, Tower Lounge and ~20,000 sq ft of event space | Conference space size 30000 sq ft and 6 meeting rooms |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Included (high-speed Wi‑Fi part of resort amenities) | |
Mondrian sits on West Avenue facing Biscayne Bay, a quieter pocket of South Beach a short drive or walk from Lincoln Road and the Art Deco District.
Choose Mondrian for bay views and a less touristy South Beach base.
The Shelborne sits on Collins Avenue steps from the Miami Beach Boardwalk and a private stretch of the Atlantic beach.
Pick The Shelborne if you want immediate beach access and to be in the heart of Collins Avenue activity.
Mondrian is an all-suite property with kitchenettes and suite configurations up to two bedrooms.
Mondrian suits travelers who want larger suites and in-room kitchenette convenience.
The Shelborne offers a broad range of room types from standard rooms to oceanfront suites and pool villa suites.
The Shelborne provides traditional hotel rooms and premium oceanfront suites for beach-focused stays.
Mondrian’s main dining is Baia Beach Club, a Mediterranean restaurant with indoor/outdoor waterfront seating.
Mondrian focuses its dining on a single signature waterfront restaurant and a lobby bar.
The Shelborne has multiple bars and lounges and an on-site full-service restaurant (Pauline) plus a coffee shop.
The Shelborne is set up for in-house variety—several bars and direct beach dining options.
Mondrian’s pool is a bow-shaped outdoor pool overlooking Biscayne Bay with curtained cabanas and loungers.
Mondrian’s pool experience centers on bay views and a design-oriented pool deck rather than ocean swimming.
The Shelborne pairs an outdoor pool with private beach access and beach-focused amenities.
The Shelborne is the clearer pick for straightforward beach days plus poolside service.
Mondrian emphasizes wellness with The Spa at Baia Beach Club and a 24-hour fitness center with wellness classes.
Mondrian suits travelers who want spa treatments and scheduled wellness offerings in a quieter setting.
The Shelborne brings Proper’s lifestyle sensibility with on-site fitness and social spaces tied to Collins Avenue energy.
The Shelborne fits guests who want an energetic South Beach base with easy access to nightlife and beachside socializing.

Mondrian — all-suite layouts with kitchenettes and larger suite options.

The Shelborne — direct private beach access and Collins Avenue location.

Mondrian — calmer bayside setting and an adult-oriented pool/spa atmosphere.

The Shelborne — steps from Lincoln Road Mall, Miami Beach Boardwalk and Ocean Drive.
The Shelborne By Proper is beachfront on Collins Avenue; Mondrian faces Biscayne Bay and is several minutes’ drive from the nearest Atlantic beach.
Both welcome children, but Mondrian skews adult-oriented in atmosphere while still accommodating families in larger suites; The Shelborne is a traditional hotel that offers family-friendly rooms and beach access.
Yes. Mondrian’s spa is The Spa at Baia Beach Club (roughly 4,000 sq ft, adult-only). The Shelborne lists an on-site, wheelchair-accessible spa, though its published name/size is not provided.
Mondrian offers 24-hour valet parking (surcharge) and an EV charging station; The Shelborne lists valet parking (surcharge) onsite.
Explore how Mondrian South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·